除去英文的对白那绝对是一部十分优秀的国产战争片。配乐、化妆以及布景可谓用心之至【英文版义勇军进行曲莫名戳中笑点】。不同于如今的国产撕鬼子“神剧”的是，虽是外国人演中国戏，却没有戏说的成分，一板一眼。有的只是自由、女权以及战争对人性的摧残，这些东西不属于中国人却也是大陆电影最需要的

如何评论这部电影，代表了你对人类绝望的程度

In the begenning is the WORD； Where is the naturalness； Maria； 塔总是在结尾把高潮做的很好，致敬

3.5. Didn't quite get the overwhelming hate this film got. The satire here is not particularly intelligent nor incisive, but that seems fitting when reality is more mundanely grotesque than fiction: it's almost like the real world does not deserve to be treated in a more aesthetically profound manner. The sense of helpless anger and disbelief at the state of the world is quite genuine, and there are emotional moments that work quite well. It's a typically white and star-studded mainstream film, and that's okay.

1，塔可夫斯基第一部长片“伊万的童年”与最后一部长片“牺牲”适合放在一起看。2，塔可夫斯基是大师，但也因此被部分人捧上了神坛，把他作品的思想无限深邃化。